Latest Section News:

Fishable, Swimmable? 40 Years of Water Law in Florida and the United States - PIEC18, February 23-25 in Gainesville

South Florida Environmental and Land Use Law: Recent Developments - March 23 in Ft. Lauderdale

Environmental and Land Use Considerations for Real Estate Transactions 2012 - April 20 in Tampa

December edition of the Section Reporter is now available online.

Energy Committee update - download the December webinar slideshow and audio!

2012 Fellowships - applications due January 20, 2012

E 1903-11 Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments: Phase II Environmental Site Assessment Process, November 17, 2011 Course material available.

Water, Wetlands, Wildlife & Beaches Committee webpage now online - join the mailing list

Practice Before DOAH - October 21 in Tallahassee - Order the CD

Agricultural Law Update - November 18 in Gainesville - Order the CD

2012 Dean Frank E. Maloney Memorial Writing Contest - brochure now available.

Annual Update 2011

Treatise - updated with 2011 content - is now online for Section Members!

Standing Since Agrico Under Chapter 120, Florida Statutes - Webinar on Monday, July 18th - Listen to the recorded program

June's Stormwater Regulation Webinar - PDF Presentation now available

Endangered Species in My Backyard - Public Interest Committee materials from the PIEC 2011

SFGAP Certification Review Course I: The Sunshine State - April 8 in Tallahassee - order the Audio CD

Land Use Committee webpage now online - join the mailing list

Hot Topics in Environmental and Land Use Law - Audio CD available

Recording & Materials available - Webinar on the State's amended rules relating to endangered or threatened species

South Florida's Culture of Corruption: Challenges for Land Use & Planning Professionals 4th Annual Seminar - Audio CD Available

Affiliate Membership List now available

July 2006

COLUMNS  
     

  Southwest Florida Water Management District Update
  Karen A. Lloyd

      

RULES

Minimum Flows

Middle Peace River, Alafia River, and Myakka River

In October and November 2005, in accordance with the District's Minimum Flows and Levels priority list, the Governing Board approved Minimum Flows for the fresh water segment of the Alafia River, the middle Peace River and the upper segment of Myakka River.

The Minimum Flows for the middle Peace River became effective on February 6, 2006. The Minimum Flows for the Myakka River became effective on April 6, 2006. A public hearing pursuant to Section 120.54(3)(c), F.S. has been requested by Tampa Bay Water on the proposed Minimum Flows for the Alafia River. Tampa Bay Water stated in its petition that it is uncertain about the effect the proposed Minimum Flows for the freshwater segment of the Alafia River will have on its water use permit which authorizes withdrawals from the estuarine portion of the Alafia River without knowing the Minimum Flows proposed for the estuarine segment of the River. Tampa Bay Water has agreed to continue the public hearing to this summer when the Governing Board has considered proposed Minimum Flows for the estuarine portion of the River.

Minimum Lake Levels

In accordance with the District's priority list, Minimum Levels were set on 20 lakes within the District over the last year.

Water Shortage Rules, 40D-21, F.A.C., Approved by Governing Board

On October 25, 2005, the District's governing board approved amendments to Chapter 40D-21, F.A.C., that substantially rewrite the District's Water Shortage Plan required by Section 373.246, F.S. and, that incorporate the water shortage measures authorized by Section 373.175, F.S. All persons and operations that are supplied with water from a private well or a utility system are covered by the Water Shortage Plan. The changes were effective April 9, 2006.

The District's water shortage plan was first adopted in 1984. The proposed amendments reflect the experience and knowledge gained through the droughts and other water shortage events that have occurred since 1984.

The proposed amendments include:

Part I, which includes updated definitions and new definitions.

Part II, which describes the District's program for monitoring conditions in anticipation of and during a Water Shortage. Part II also identifies and quantifies the factors that the District will consider in declaring or rescinding a Water Shortage. The Water Shortage Plan establishes four water shortage phases: Phase I, Moderate Water Shortage, Phase II Severe Water Shortage, Phase III Extreme Water Shortage, and Phase IV Critical Water Shortage.

Part III establishes the procedures for declaring and implementing a Water Shortage Emergency when the provisions of Part II are insufficient to protect the water resource and its users.

Part IV, describes how the District, in conjunction with local governmental entities and law enforcement officials, will enforce the provisions of a declared Water Shortage or Water Shortage Emergency. A new feature of the Water Shortage Plan is that local water suppliers are given the option of submitting to the District a water shortage mitigation plan that is customized for the supplier’s system for approval and which may be implemented in lieu of selected provisions of the Water Shortage Plan.

Part V, classifies each user according to the source of water supply, type of water use and method of withdrawal. These classifications are utilized in conjunction with Parts I, II, III and VI. The use classifications include Indoor Uses, Essential Uses, Commercial and Industrial Uses, Agricultural Uses, Landscape Uses, Cemeteries, Golf Courses, Driving Ranges and Other Athletic Play Areas.

Part VI, presents water use restrictions and other response mechanisms for each Water Shortage Phase and Water Use Class.

Southern Water Use Caution Area

On May 12, the Governing Board approved amendments to Chapters 40D-2, 40D-8 and 40D-80, FAC, establishing Minimum Flows and Levels in the SWUCA and establishing the regulatory portion of the recovery strategy for those Minimum Flows and Levels.

The Governing Board approved amendments include the establishment of the Minimum Flows for the upper Peace River, and Minimum Levels for the coastal portion of the Floridan Aquifer in Hillsborough, Manatee and Sarasota Counties and eight lakes in the Highlands Ridge area. The window will close on June 2, 2006 for any requests for hearings.

The principle focus of the regulatory portion of the recovery strategy is the reduction of ground water withdrawals to allow recovery to the Minimum Aquifer Level. If a proposed withdrawal of new quantities impacts a water body with an actual flow or level that is below the Minimum Flow or Level, then no new quantities of water will be permitted unless the proposed withdrawal will provide a net benefit to the impacted water body. The proposed rules describe the three types of net benefit that can be proposed.

In order to maximize the efficient utilization of water resources in the SWUCA so as to allow for recovery, the District is proposing rules that will emphasize that new and renewal water use permits applicants must demonstrate a reasonable-beneficial use, that conservation measures will be implemented and alternative sources of water will be utilized to the extent economically, technically and environmentally feasible.

The proposed rules include a method for calculating public water supply service area population so that the calculation of population size is standardized for utilities within the Southern Water Use Caution Area. This standardization is integral to determining compliance with per capita daily water use rule requirements and developing future per capita daily water use standards.

The proposed rules repeal the Highlands Water Use Caution Area and the Eastern Tampa Bay Water Use Caution Area.

In addition to the regulatory component of the recovery strategy for the Minimum Flows and Levels established in the SWUCA, the District developed a comprehensive financial and resource development component that is designed to target recovery of the upper Peace River and lakes to their established Minimum Flows and Levels.


OTHER MATTERS

Interdistrict Transfer Approved to Supply Polk County

The Tohopekaliga Water Authority ("Toho"), and Polk County entered into an Interlocal Agreement that contemplates that Toho will temporarily provide Polk County's Northeast Regional Utility Service Area ("NERUSA") with potable water supply for up to five years. Polk County is subject to a consent order with the Southwest Florida Water Management District ("Southwest") to refrain from overpumping under its permit and develop additional sources of water to meet water use demands in the NERUSA. Toho's withdrawal facilities are located in the South Florida Water Management District ("South Florida") and the County's NERUSA is located within the Southwest.

Toho applied to South Florida to modify its permit to allow an interdistrict transfer of up to 3.75 mgd to Polk County for use within Southwest.

Section 373.223(3), F.S., provides a process for the "interdistrict transfer" through the withdrawal of groundwater in one water management district and the use of that water in another water management district. The application is filed with the water management district in which the withdrawals are proposed to be made. Only a permit from that district, based on its permitting criteria, is required for the interdistrict transfer. The comments of the district within which the water will be used must be attached to the notice of proposed action. In applying the public interest test, the Governing Board must consider the future water needs of the area of the withdrawal and the area of use. If both needs can be met, and all other permitting criteria are met, the permit shall be issued. An additional notice of proposed action is required. If requested, DEP reviews the intended action and issues a final order.

The South Florida Governing Board approved the transfer, subject to Toho, Polk County, Southwest and South Florida entering into an agreement that contains the provisions specified by the South Florida Governing Board. The South Florida Governing Board sought assurances that the water was in fact needed by Polk County, that the County's need is temporary because it will have other sources on line within five years to meet water supply demands, and that all parties acknowledge that the interdistrict transfer approval is good only for five years. An agreement was reached and Polk County and Toho are now authorized undertake the interdistrict transfer.

Executive Director's Emergency Water Shortage Order

On May 11, 2006, the District's Executive Director issued an Emergency Order authorizing Tampa Bay Water to augment the City of Tampa's public supply reservoir due to low water elevations resulting from dry weather conditions.

The District had not declared a water shortage for any part of the District, but the City of Tampa's surface water reservoir's declining water supply warranted an emergency order allowing supplementation of the supply to protect public health, safety and welfare.

The Order authorizes Tampa Bay Water to make withdrawal diversions from, and to lower the stage in, the Middle Pool of the Tampa Bypass Canal to a level at or above 10 feet, NGVD (1929), measured upstream of Structure S-162 while maintaining a head differential across Structure S-161 that shall not exceed a maximum of 12 feet, subject to the terms and conditions to be imposed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.



 

Copyright © 2012, The Environmental and Land Use Law Section of The Florida Bar